Top 5 Restaurants in Islamorada

Islamorada isn’t just the Sportfishing Capital of the World - it’s also one of the best places in the Florida Keys for food lovers. This string of islands has been feeding travelers since the 1940s, and many of its best restaurants are local staples with decades of history, waterfront views, and plenty of fresh-caught seafood. Whether you want to bring your catch to be cooked, or just enjoy a slice of Key lime pie at sunset, these are the top restaurants in Islamorada to experience real-deal island dining.

‍

5. Morada Bay Beach Café

Al Fresco Island Dining with Sunset Views

• 📍 MM 81.6, Bayside
• 🌅 Beachfront tables right in the sand - toes-in-the-water dining
• 🥘 Caribbean-American menu with fresh fish, ceviche, paella, and more
• 🍹 The Key Lime Colada is a fan favorite
• 📝 Tip: Check their calendar for live music nights or the famous Full Moon Parties

‍

4. Robbie’s Hungry Tarpon

Rustic Marina Eatery with a Side of Tarpon Feeding

• 📍 Robbie’s Marina, MM 77.5, Bayside
• 🎣 Feed giant tarpon right off the dock before or after your meal
• 🌴 Open-air tiki cafe with tons of local charm
• 🌮 Don’t miss the mahi Reuben or the “Trailer Trash” Bloody Mary
• 📝 Tip: Great spot for early breakfast or casual lunch with unbeatable character

‍

3. Lazy Days Restaurant

“Cook Your Catch” and Keys Classics by the Sea

• 📍 MM 79.8, Oceanside
• 🎣 Bring your own catch-they’ll cook it Lazy Days style
• 🐠 Signature topping: panko breadcrumbs, tomato, onion, and cheese
• 🍤 Local hits like hogfish almondine and conch fritters
• 📝 Tip: Ask for a seat on the upper deck for the best ocean view

‍

2. Marker 88

Sunset Dining & Keys Tradition Since 1967

• 📍 MM 88, Bayside (Plantation Key)
• 🌅 Dine with your feet in the sand and a sunset in front of you
• 🐟 Try the grilled yellowtail snapper or fried grouper bites
• 🍸 House-made Key lime pie and tropical cocktails are musts
• 📝 Tip: Come early for sunset and get a seat under the palm trees or tiki torches

‍

1. Green Turtle Inn

Historic Roadside Diner Turned Keys Landmark

• 📍 MM 81.2, Bayside
• 🐢 Open since 1947 - a true Old Keys icon
• 🍳 Known for conch Benedict, fresh seafood, and generous breakfasts
• 🥧 Save room for the famous homemade Key lime pie
• 📝 Tip: Even if you’re just passing through, this is a must-stop spot for Keys history and hospitality

‍

🧭 Final Word

If you’re wondering where to eat in Islamorada, this list has you covered - from historic diners to beachside cafes with killer sunsets. Each of these Islamorada restaurants offers a true taste of the Keys: unfussy, fresh, and full of local charm.